Getting the water out
Posted: Mon Aug 09, 2010 12:24 pm
Water is the enemy of good vacuum, as anyone with a residual gas analyzer knows, especially if you have Viton seals anywhere, which allow a little through.
Well, I do have an RGA, so I know what works and what doesn't. Here is some info on what works, and what doesn't do much.
Starting off, here's an old table of drying agents used "back in the day". The physics hasn't changed since, so it's still good and matches what I measure here. Note the odd units -- a liter is less than a mole of gas in the ratio 1/22.4, and mg is a mg, so you have to do a little dance with units to get to percentages. One mg of water
is 0.000055556 mole of it (assuming 18 mol weight). One liter of a gas is 0.044642857 mole of it at STP. So one mg/liter works out to .001244454 or about 1.2%.
As you can see, even after some pretty good drying agents are used, there's still a pretty big partial pressure of water in the cleaned gas. But look at liquid air temperatures!
Now, that's going places. This has led a lot of people to assume that dry ice would be nearly as good, but sadly, it's not so great. At the temperature of dry ice-acetone mix,
which is about -78c the vapor pressure of ice is still e-3 millimeter of mercury (a little more in millbars, 1000 millibars == 760 millimeters of Hg) or so. So some of the inexpensive
chemicals are actually better than a dry ice trap.
So if you want a low partial pressure in your tank, for say D made in an electolyzer, you'd better dry it while the gas is at high pressure and have the fact that the proportions
stay the same as it becomes rarefied in the tank stay the same work for you. For that special case, we've seen noticeable (and bad, depending on what you are doing) effects
from as little as .3% water in the introduced gas.
There is a further trap with cold traps, often called virtual leaks. This happens if the level of coolant is allowed to change during use. As some of the trapped ice gets above the coolant,
the temperature there rises and the stuff re-evaporates into your vacuum. Most people work around this by starting at room temperature, pumping for awhile, then slowly
adding the coolant, a little at a time, so most of the junk is in the bottom of the trap, not right up at the top, but it is something to watch out for. If you could arrange for a slowly
rising level of coolant you would -- but you hit the top of the trap at some point....Cryo kinds of things bring their own problems to the table in general.
For getting out water that's already in the tank, full speed pumping plus heating is the usual way. You can bake to a few hundred degrees C in a fully metal gasket setup, but have to stay down around 100 C if you have Viton in the system, or it starts to decompose. Here we have found that bright short UV works better yet, and nothing
really works as well as the combination of UV, ions , and electrons from a big glow discharge, even if you have to let in something like Argon to get up to the glow pressure,
then pump it all back out. Of course if you are a purist and can afford it, you'd use the real process gas for this part too so as to avoid putting in anything that wasn't
what you were going to want in there later on. Water is a sticky polar molecule and is hard to remove, but deadly when it reacts with things in the tank, like tungsten
for example -- it erodes tungsten in a cycle that doesn't wind up eliminating the water. What the short UV does is simply break up the water into H's and O's and those are far easier to pump
out than the water was, and they will be carried out in the glow gas when that is pumped away. Ions and high speed electrons, ditto -- they break up the water so you are
only pumping some plain gasses, which aren't as sticky as water is.
If you can arrange for that glow discharge to evaporate or sputter some titanium onto the tank walls, so much the better -- Ti is a fantastic "getter" under those conditions and will tie up the water as Ti compounds. The only problem there is preventing metallic Ti from winding up on things that are supposed to be insulators, so you need to pay attention to the mechanical design so as to "shadow" those from the Ti atoms flying about, in more or less straight lines, so it's not impossible, just something you have to pay attention to. Barium and Calcium work well too, but are a little weird to handle for the average experimenter. They were use extensively in vacuum tubes which could be pre baked a lot hotter than any vacuum tank can be, and of course are a one-shot deal.
Well, I do have an RGA, so I know what works and what doesn't. Here is some info on what works, and what doesn't do much.
Starting off, here's an old table of drying agents used "back in the day". The physics hasn't changed since, so it's still good and matches what I measure here. Note the odd units -- a liter is less than a mole of gas in the ratio 1/22.4, and mg is a mg, so you have to do a little dance with units to get to percentages. One mg of water
is 0.000055556 mole of it (assuming 18 mol weight). One liter of a gas is 0.044642857 mole of it at STP. So one mg/liter works out to .001244454 or about 1.2%.
As you can see, even after some pretty good drying agents are used, there's still a pretty big partial pressure of water in the cleaned gas. But look at liquid air temperatures!
Now, that's going places. This has led a lot of people to assume that dry ice would be nearly as good, but sadly, it's not so great. At the temperature of dry ice-acetone mix,
which is about -78c the vapor pressure of ice is still e-3 millimeter of mercury (a little more in millbars, 1000 millibars == 760 millimeters of Hg) or so. So some of the inexpensive
chemicals are actually better than a dry ice trap.
So if you want a low partial pressure in your tank, for say D made in an electolyzer, you'd better dry it while the gas is at high pressure and have the fact that the proportions
stay the same as it becomes rarefied in the tank stay the same work for you. For that special case, we've seen noticeable (and bad, depending on what you are doing) effects
from as little as .3% water in the introduced gas.
There is a further trap with cold traps, often called virtual leaks. This happens if the level of coolant is allowed to change during use. As some of the trapped ice gets above the coolant,
the temperature there rises and the stuff re-evaporates into your vacuum. Most people work around this by starting at room temperature, pumping for awhile, then slowly
adding the coolant, a little at a time, so most of the junk is in the bottom of the trap, not right up at the top, but it is something to watch out for. If you could arrange for a slowly
rising level of coolant you would -- but you hit the top of the trap at some point....Cryo kinds of things bring their own problems to the table in general.
For getting out water that's already in the tank, full speed pumping plus heating is the usual way. You can bake to a few hundred degrees C in a fully metal gasket setup, but have to stay down around 100 C if you have Viton in the system, or it starts to decompose. Here we have found that bright short UV works better yet, and nothing
really works as well as the combination of UV, ions , and electrons from a big glow discharge, even if you have to let in something like Argon to get up to the glow pressure,
then pump it all back out. Of course if you are a purist and can afford it, you'd use the real process gas for this part too so as to avoid putting in anything that wasn't
what you were going to want in there later on. Water is a sticky polar molecule and is hard to remove, but deadly when it reacts with things in the tank, like tungsten
for example -- it erodes tungsten in a cycle that doesn't wind up eliminating the water. What the short UV does is simply break up the water into H's and O's and those are far easier to pump
out than the water was, and they will be carried out in the glow gas when that is pumped away. Ions and high speed electrons, ditto -- they break up the water so you are
only pumping some plain gasses, which aren't as sticky as water is.
If you can arrange for that glow discharge to evaporate or sputter some titanium onto the tank walls, so much the better -- Ti is a fantastic "getter" under those conditions and will tie up the water as Ti compounds. The only problem there is preventing metallic Ti from winding up on things that are supposed to be insulators, so you need to pay attention to the mechanical design so as to "shadow" those from the Ti atoms flying about, in more or less straight lines, so it's not impossible, just something you have to pay attention to. Barium and Calcium work well too, but are a little weird to handle for the average experimenter. They were use extensively in vacuum tubes which could be pre baked a lot hotter than any vacuum tank can be, and of course are a one-shot deal.